Launching The Startup Catalyst™ Podcast - Part 1

Launching The Startup Catalyst™ Podcast  - Part 1

On May 12, 2016, I sat at my desk in The Sultan Ventures HQ in downtown Honolulu and with the click of a button, officially launched The Startup Catalyst™ Podcast into the ether.

Of course, a lot went into that launch moment, and much of that I'm going to share with you in this post and the two that will follow.

Since launching, we've welcomed over a dozen guests, launched a bonus episode, and I have been having a blast recording the shows and learning a lot along the way.

This is Part 1 of a 3-part series where I will be writing about the process of researching, creating, launching, analyzing and promoting The Startup Catalyst™ Podcast.

Part 1: The Landscape, The Why, The Concept
Part 2: The Interviews, The Gear, The Editing, The Launch

Part 3: The Analytics, The Promotion, The Future

While the jury is definitely still out on whether we have launched a successful podcast, the show has gotten some good early feedback and reviews on iTunes:

insert itunes review img

insert img

insert img

For much more detail on the statistics and progress to date on the podcast, see the post I wrote on recapping our first 45-days.

I will say this, I do not measure the "success" of the show by pure downloads alone. As I mentioned, this effort has brand and community benefits that get baked into an overall success calculation.

What to expect in these posts

This series includes step by step analysis, tips of what to do (and not do) and even a few email templates and checklists. Also included are links to helpful resources, and a list of all the tools we use to publish the podcast.

For sure, this is the most ambitious writing endeavor for the blog that I have taken on, clocking in at over 5,000 words in aggregate.

The Landscape: Podcasting Statistics

Audio is back like it's 1975, and it's back in a big way. I wanted to kick off the post with some high level trends and statistics to sort of set the stage for what market landscape we are launching our new podcast into.

1 in 5 people in America subscribe to podcasts. That's basically 57 million domestically tuning in to at least one podcast per month.

insert img

In fact, more Americans listen to podcasts than actively use Twitter on a monthly basis.

The most recent industry trend report I found was an Edison "The Infinite Dial" post. Some key takeaways from that report:

  • People like good content and will find it eventually.
  • The mobile phone has been the #1 reason podcasting has grown so rapidly.
  • Social media has contributed to the spread of podcasting (again, going back to good content will get found and shared). It's just now you're beginning to see the numbers show mass market adoption.
  • People listen to 5-shows per week on average. The folks over at Convince and Convert believe there's an interesting correlation to our 5-day work week commutes and gym habits. I'd tend to agree with that hypothesis.
  • The growth trend of podcasting is part of the confluence of multiple things including online radio overall, streaming service popularity (ie Netflix binge-watching), and the ubiquity of social media to name a few.

Other industry pundits and tech leaders have recently weighed in on the future of the medium.

Ben Thompson from Stratechery outlines several key points in his Future of Podcasting post:

  • People don't make money with podcasts. Or do they? Ben quotes a range as big as $34M - $200M in terms of annual advertising. Regardless, it's tiny as he says the billboard market is $3B annually.
  • Major challenge in podcast advertising is the complete lack of accurate data.
  • The "Facebookization" of podcasting is a real threat and he gets into what all that means. I won't repeat it here, but essentially there is an understanding that big money is coming into podcasts and the landscape of what that looks like is somewhat scary for small indie publishers.

For an interesting read on how the best in the biz approaches his podcast: see Tim Ferriss's post "How I launched a #1 podcast with 60M+ downloads".

I posed an interesting question to Google about the difference between Radio and Podcasts. Google didnt say much, but there are some narratives around the differences (I won't get into them here, suffice to say we're going to see more audio innovation and potential "rebranding" of terms). And we'll see more products like, who profess to be "radio for the people".

insert image

Anchor is an interesting NYC startup essentially being an audio-centric social network

Podcasting is still in its infancy I believe and if the data points to anything, it's that people will continue to listen as long as the quality of content is there. With more and more people producing podcasts, discovery, analytics and curation will continue to be key. I expect to see more innovation in the space, which is exciting for podcast listeners and producers.

The Why: After all, Podcasting Aint for the Faint of Heart

I had thought for sometime I wanted to host a podcast show and as many know I'm a big fan of them. Podcasts are a lot of work, make no mistake. But I figured the "juice was worth the squeeze".

Here's my reasons why I thought it made sense:

  1. Applying a bit of systems thinking, which is basically to invest into win in scenarios. In that if you fail, you'll still have won because you would have learned x new skill or gained y new relationship(s). Scott Adams, the Dilbert creator talks about it in his interview with Tim Ferriss. This is an example of one of those: learning to interview is a great skill, and getting the chance to talk to interesting people is irreplaceable. Even if nobody else listened, I would still get value. Mr. Tim himself says this was also the reason he launched his podcast, knowing it would improve his interviewing skills, and ultimately help him write better books. The podcast grew into something else entirely and is now one of his primary points of focus and creativity.

  2. Content like this podcast essentially acts as a community service (just like Greater Good Radio). Creating a knowledge repository for current and future entrepreneurs. It's inevitably going to be part of the fabric of what's happening right now, so these interviews are like mini time capsules.

  3. Build thought leadership for Sultan Ventures. To me, this comes down to the personality, quality, and distribution of content. Expanding our reach to showcase amazing things across the brand, provide a marketing channel for community members, clients, portfolio companies, and partners; and be a good citizen of the Startup Paradise community and the startup community as a whole.

  4. To learn and experiment with new production and creative mediums. Podcasting is great because it's a very personal medium, and it can be a fun creative outlet.

  5. Build up my personal brand and be seen as a connector / person in the know.

So I made the decision that I wanted to start a show. Now, what should the show be about?

The Concept: Creating the Concept of the Show

The original premise was simple: Talk to entrepreneurs and investors on the catalysts that led to their startup successes or failures. Do this with an emphasis on Hawaii's startup community.

Here's an image of the original premise google doc that I created outlining the basics as I saw them then:

insert img

Now, to be sure, some of the things have been refined as we've moved along but in general this outline remains pretty accurate.

A major goal of the podcast that I want to emphasize is this: In Hawaii, people talk about the proverbial "brain drain". I tend to think there are a lot of talented people here, and instead of a story of brain drain, we are showing that Hawaii's talented entrepreneurs and investors can be a source of knowledge that could help people in other communities.

Hawaii as a startup knowledge exporter, so to speak.

As Chenoa mentions in my interview with her, the Startup Paradise community has more brand awareness then people may think. Personally, I have seen and heard of other communities that are where Hawaii was maybe 3 years ago.

As we progress, I see the mission expanding to include helping tell the story of startups that are not in the major tech hubs, emphasizing this "Rise of the Rest" and democratization of entrepreneurship that folks like Village Capital have built a brand and fund around, and even groups like Tech Stars and their "Rising Stars" remote mentorship program. There are some new interviews coming soon which highlight this.

From day 1 the structure of the show was chosen to be Long form interview style. This is for two main reasons:

  1. By far the biggest reason is editing. Long form interview means minimal editing. That's probably the biggest hindrance for people being consistent with their podcasting.
  2. I have a curious mind. Seriously, every person I've interviewed, I felt I could keep asking them questions. As long as it's interesting and engaging, then great.

We also chose to do audio only first, just because doing video is another layer of complexity and I wanted to remove as many barriers of execution risk as possible.

What's The Target Length?
My interviews thus far have been clocking in right around 50 - 55 minutes. Buffer says the ideal length is 22 minutes based upon people's attention span. I do know there's shows that are in that range, hence the brilliance behind the 20 minute VC.

Here's a tip though, listen to podcasts at 2x speed. In the iTunes app, when you're playing an episode, click on the small, horizontal bar at the bottom where the episode is playing and then on the left you can see a "1x". Just tap that a few times and you'll be blazing at mach 2.

insert img
This was #68 on my "Startups are Hard" post

But I wanted to create a podcast that was like many of the ones I was listening too, of which most are long form interviews (James Altucher, Tim Ferriss, Greylock's Blitzscaling). Granted, a few of my non-long form interview format podcasts are the likes of 99% invisible, Gastropod, and Startup Class.

All that being said, we definitely plan on playing with some other formats to keep it fresh and make sure we're still having fun and people are enjoying the comments.

to be continued...

So what's next?

Crafting an idea is truly just the beginning. The next post is the biggest of the three - I write about who I started interviewing and how I convinced them to be on the show, how I approach an interview, what recording gear I use, and more.

Next week I'll post Part 2: The Interviews, The Gear, The Editing, The Launch

Links & Resources:

Showrunner: A podcast about podcasts. See the most recent episodes, now turned into a mini course on how to create, launch, and grow a successful podcast show.

Buffer's post: Podcasting for beginners has good insights and info (oddly enough, as much as I love Buffer's content, I didn't find this post until after I launched the podcast).

Other links:

Special thanks to Evan Leong for his input, guidance, and encouragement.

Of course, special thanks to my colleagues at Sultan Ventures for their support and assistance with this. To Omar and Tarik for seeing and supporting the vision. And shoutout to Lauren, Rose, Quinn, and Jack for all their help - it wouldn't be possible without them. To all my guests, you have my undying gratitude for being on the show!

If you have a story you'd like to tell and you think you'd be a good fit for The Startup Catalyst™ Podcast, hit me up on twitter, @luketucker, or email me: luke[at]

Subscribe to Luke Tucker

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.